Case Summaries Category Archives

Surujdeo v. Melady, 2017 ONCA 41

The Court of Appeal clarifies the causation question to be put to the jury in medical malpractice trials (and lots more). Released January 18, 2017 | Full Decision [CanLII] This action was brought by the surviving spouse of a 36-year-old woman, Rossana Surujdeo, who presented to hospital with flu like symptoms and died approximately 9 hours later. The cause of her death was a rare …

Dunk v. Kremer, 2017 ONSC 1547

This is a Costs Hearing subsequent to the Judgment by Healey J., with respect to a Motor Vehicle Accident Claim with a particular focus on SABS deductibility Released March 7, 2017 | Full decision [CanLII] Two of the most pressing issues to be decided by the Court were: The amount, if any, of any deduction for collateral benefits to be made from Meaghan Dunk’s award; The scale …

J.I.L.M. Enterprises & Investments Ltd v. Intact Insurance, 2017 ONSC 357

This fire loss trial resulted in an award to the plaintiff for its losses under the policy, extended profits losses due to insurer delay and a punitive award to denounce the high handed insurer behavior in delaying payment two years.

Sabean v. Portage La Prairie Mutual Insurance Co., 2017 SCC 7

An insurer cannot rely on its specialized knowledge of jurisprudence to advance an interpretation of the policy that goes beyond the clear words of the policy as understood by an average person.

Shaw v. Mkheyan, 2017 ONSC 851

This is a threshold motion in which the plaintiff had pre-existing osteoarthritis in his left knee. The plaintiff was successful in establishing the subject car accident caused his asymptomatic left knee to become symptomatic and thus his injuries met threshold.