Case Summaries Category Archives

Persampieri v. Hobbs, 2018 ONSC 368 (CanLII)

In a recent costs endorsement against Aviva, the Court held that insurers who took positions on modest claims that necessitated a trial should not be allowed to rely on a strict application of the proportionality principle in determining costs. The Court held that as Aviva had made a tactical decision to reject a Rule 49 offer that the Plaintiff beat at trial, it should bear the full magnitude of the consequences of that strategy. Although the Plaintiff was ultimately awarded only $20,414.83 for her damages, the court ordered a costs award of $237,017.50 payable to the Plaintiff.

Liu v. The Personal Insurance Company et al, 2018 ONSC 324 (CanLII)

This is a motion to withdraw an admission made during oral submissions at a previous summary judgment motion and to amend certain paragraphs of that summary judgment decision.

Ferreira v. St. Mary’s General Hospital, 2017 ONSC 6631 (CanLII)

Co-operators General Insurance Company v. Doobay, 2017 ONSC 5804 (CanLII)