Case Summaries Category Archives

Richards v. Sun Life Assurance Company of Canada et. al, 2016 ONSC 5492

Ladies and Gentlemen, start your engines….and your Statement of Claims. This recent summary judgement dismissal suggests that an insurer’s delay in paying a benefit will trigger the commencement of the limitation clock, even where there has not been a “clear and unequivocal denial” of the disability claim.

The limitation period for disability benefits does not require a clear and unequivocal denial according to Justice Bale in his fact-specific decision on Summary Judgment motion.

Woodhouse v. Snow Valley Resorts (1987) Ltd., 2017 ONSC 222

Where a service provider relies on the waiver clause of a consumer agreement, and the consumer agreement contains terms that are void by operation of the Consumer Protection Act, the service provider bears the onus to persuade the court that it would be inequitable not to bind the Plaintiff to all or some portions of the consumer agreement, including its waiver clause.

Sobh v. RBC General Insurance Co. et al, 2016 ONSC 7382

This was a motion and cross-motion for summary judgment. The defendant driver sought to have the claim dismissed as against him and his numbered company. The Plaintiff’s insurer sought its release from the action under its unidentified coverage. In the alternative, it sought a ruling that the OPCF 44R was not triggered in the circumstances of this claim.

Denis v. Lalonde, 2016 ONSC 5960

This was a motion by the Plaintiff to compel productions and attendance at examinations for discovery of an insurance broker after the matter had been set down for trial in which conflicting authorities were reviewed.