Injured at work: How the employee-employer relationship affects the right to sue

construction worker at a dangerous job site

If you are injured while working, determining whether you are a worker or an independent operator is a critical question that could decide your right to sue for damages.

Although a third party can still be sued, the Workplace Safety and Insurance Act, 1997 (WSIA) denies a worker’s right to sue their employer(s) if that worker is in the course of their employment when injured. Independent operators are not considered workers however, and their right to sue an employer is not restricted by the WSIA.

The Workplace Safety and Insurance Board (WSIB) is the sole authority capable of determining whether a person’s right to sue an employer is taken away. The WSIB has the final word on the matter, and its decision is not open to question or review in court.

In considering the question of whether a person is a worker as opposed to independent operator, the WSIB must consider the factors outlined in the WSIA, the decisions of the Workplace Safety and Insurance Tribunals (a separate entity from the WSIB, where workers and employers may bring disputes concerning workplace safety), and the policies of the WSIB.

Factors relevant to the WSIB include:

Contract of Service An agreement to work for an employer on a full or part-time basis, where the employer has the right to control what, where, when, and how work is performed is indicative of a worker.
Contract for Service An agreement to perform specific work in return for payment, with control over when and in what manner the work is done, is indicative of an independent operator.
Equipment Ownership If the injured person is using equipment owned by the employer, the indication is that they are a worker.
Compensation The ability to negotiate amount and method of payment is indicative of an independent operator.
Business Indicia Those operating under a business name, registered as a business or corporation, or invoicing for services rendered are typically independent operators.
Intention of Parties Whether the parties intend the business relationship be worker-employer or independent operator is given substantial weight by the WSIB if supported by objective facts.
Economic Market If the injured person had the opportunity to increase their profit, and carried the risk of loss, this indicates an independent operator.
Substitute Service If the injured person can hire others to complete work without their employer’s consent, this is indicative of an independent operator.
Degree of Integration If the injured person could be considered integral to the operation of the business, it is likely that they are a worker.

This list of factors includes some common considerations, but the WSIB uses a flexible, adaptive approach, focusing on the reality of the business relationship in the unique context of each case. Since business relationships can take a variety of forms, it is important to retain legal advice if you are unsure of your status in the workplace. This may determine whether you can sue your employer for damages, or whether an alternative course of action is necessary.

Written by

As an associate and civil litigator with Siskinds’ personal injury law group, Maciek aims to provide high quality legal services and focuses on making himself available and accessible to his clients. With a primary focus on personal injury cases and insurance disputes, his practice includes motor vehicle accidents, slip and falls, injuries at work, assaults, tavern negligence, and long term disability benefit and pension disputes.

Prior to obtaining his Bachelor of Laws and his Honours Bachelor of Arts in history from Western University, Maciek was actively involved in practical dispute resolution exercises, advocacy skills training, and competing in appellate moots and mock trials. During his time at Western, Maciek was also a committed student orientation program volunteer and a relentless intramural sport participant.

Maciek moved to London, Ontario, in 1989 from Krasnik, Poland, and has since become a lifetime Londoner, developing strong ties to the City of London and Southwestern Ontario.

1 Comment

  • Injured and Still Working? You Still Deserve Compensation | Ashley Gnys Personal Injury Law
    May 29, 2019 - 8:52 am