Summary prepared for OTLA by Corina Bachmann of Bachmann Personal Injury Law Full Decision This case addresses the issue of what is a “reasonable explanation” for submitting the OCF-1 outside the timeline mandated by the Statutory Accident Benefits Schedule (SABS). The applicant, Ms. Buttenham, was involved in a motor vehicle collision on May 29, 2018. She advised her insurer of the collision the following day, …
McLean v Primmum Insurance Company, 2023 CanLII 84386 (ON LAT)
Full Decision This case involves a dispute between the plaintiff and her insurer over the payment of Income Replacement Benefits (“IRBs”) beyond the first two years following the collision. The plaintiff was injured in a motor vehicle collision (“MVC”) on November 18, 2018. At the time of the collision, she was working at Mohawk College as a part-time professor teaching recreation therapy 1-6 hours per …
Moustakis v. Agbuya, voir dire heard October 17, 2023 in the Ont SCJ
This was a voir dire heard by The Honourable Madam Justice L. Merritt. It involves a challenge by the plaintiff to one of the defence experts. Counsel for the defendants asked Merritt J. to qualify Dr. Michael Ford as an orthopaedic surgeon with experience in chronic pain and somatic symptom disorder; and the diagnosis, prognosis, causation and impairments relating to functionality and impairment. Counsel for the plaintiff opposed and asked the Court to exercise its jurisdiction as a gatekeeper and exclude Dr. Ford’s evidence, arguing that the cost of admitting his evidence outweighs its probative value.
Majerczyk v. Manalo, 2023 ONSC 3064
This ruling involves a motion brought by the defendant for leave to call more than three experts at trial, and more specifically, a physiatrist and an orthopaedic surgeon.
Bustin v. Quaranto, 2023 ONSC 5732
This case involves a plaintiff who claimed personal injury damages after witnessing a very serious collision and its aftermath. The plaintiff happened to stand outside his aunt’s home when two cars collided and he
McKee v. Hicks, 2023 BCCA 109 Part 2
In Part I of my reporting on this case, which can be found here, I looked at the court’s decision regarding the award of damages for loss of future earning capacity. The same decision also addressed the circumstances of when an award of damages for loss of housekeeping capacity should be awarded and how.

